Grappling Standard
Once again you will find below a comparison of the World Hapkido Federation, Dr' Kimm's Hapkido, the HWA RANG DO and the KUK SOOL WON Breathing material .
The 1st group of Grappling Techniques shared by 4 out of the four groups and
these are coded Blue.
The 2nd group are Techniques shared by 3 out of four and these are
coded Green.
The 3rd group are Techniques shared by 2 out of 4-- Violet.
The 4th group are for Techniques that are unique to only one out of the four.
They are Auburn.
It is important to remember that there is a lot of redundancy in these curriculums so what I have done is accepted the first representation of a technique in its gross bio-mechanic. "Arm bar"-s are probably the single most represented and over-represented technique. It follows that the techniques are often repeated as clothing grabs, wrist grabs, two-handed-grabs and finally in response to striking or kicking. To keep things uniform most of the representations were observed to have been made in the earliest levels of each Hapkido art.
THEN there is the "small" matter of terminology. We are probably
going to be working on terms for quite some time to come. As you can see most
people have gotten around the importance of terms by simply using a numbering
system. Unfortunately not everyone has placed the same importance on techniques
in the same order so one person's "#2" could well be someone else's
"#15". We definitely have our work cut out here. I have tried to use
some common terms but found myself falling back on Japanese terms ("koto
gaeshi") simply for convenience sake. To me this would be like describing
Tennis in Baseball terms and whatever the connections between Japanese and
Korean traditions I am looking for the Korean techniques and terms to stand on
their own.
Lastly, I direct your attention to the number of KSW techniques down in the
"single representation (violet) section. I mention these in particular as
they bear a shocking resemblance to the hapkiyusool techniques taught by Dojunim
Kim at the YONG SUL KWAN. The order is just a bit varied, though, overall even
that is pretty close. I found some of the same material in Kimm's Hapkido but
have to defer to the fact that Kimm is essentially a KSW person at heart if not
always in practice. Just an intriguing artifact. I think if I get time I will
pair-up the KSW techniques to their YSK counterparts just for curiosity sake and
post it in case anyone is curious. It does not actually relate well to the other
material as we are essentially functioning on the YU SOOL level with most of
what we have here and I didn't want to start mixing levels. It would be real
easy to get side tracked into discussing where "ki-ai" material stops
and "ai-ki" material starts. See--- even there that Japanese
terminology pops into the discussion. Thoughts on this last posting would be
welcome.
Yon Mu Kwan / WHF |
He-Young Kimm (Hapkido) |
Hwa Rang Do |
Kuk Sool Won (Suh) |
1.) Wrist Throw |
Oht 11 Soo |
Wrist Break Throw |
Ki Bon 5 Soo |
2. Hammerlock |
Son Mok 22 Soo |
Shoulder Dislocate |
Ki Bon 4 Soo |
3. Leg Sweep |
Son Mok 14 Soo |
Sweeping Throw |
Ki Bon 9 Soo |
4. Figure 4 Lock |
Son Mok 17 Soo |
Elbow Break |
Son Mok 10 Soo |
5. Shoulder Throw |
Son Mok 11 Soo |
Overthrow |
Son Mok 7 Soo |
6. Elbow Pressure |
Son Mok 6 Soo |
Ki Bon 6 Soo |
|
7. Bent Arm Throw |
Son Mok 10 Soo |
Ki Bon 3 Soo |
|
8. Hip Throw |
Son Mok 12 Soo |
Ki Bon 14 Soo |
|
9. Inverse |
Son Mok 7 Soo |
Son Mok 2 Soo |
|
10.Verticle Wristlock |
Oht 7 Soo |
Son Mok 3 Soo |
|
11. Horizontal Head/Neck Throw |
Oht 13 Soo |
Ki Bon 10 Su |
|
12. Elbow-in-Armpit |
Son Mok 8 Soo |
Elbow Break |
|
13. Figure - 4 Throw |
Oht 15 Soo |
Wrist, Elbow, Shoulder Break |
|
14. Horizon Throw |
Wrist Pressure Point Throw |
Ki Bon 13 Soo |
|
15 |
Oht 4 Soo |
Dislocate Spine |
Ki Bon 12 Soo |
16. Exiting Straight-arm Fig-4 |
Son Mok 21 Soo |
||
17. Knifehand-to-elbow Draw |
Son Mok 23 Soo |
||
18. Forward Fireman's Throw |
Son Mok 13 Soo |
||
19. Dbl Elbow-lock Shoulder Throw |
Son Mok 24 Soo |
||
20. Wrist Lock |
Wrist Breaking & Kick |
||
21. Forward 180 |
Wrist Shoulder Break |
||
22. Grapevine Throw |
Collarbone Break |
||
23. Primary Shoulderlock |
Elbow Break |
||
24. Rearward 180 |
Ki Bon 1 Soo |
||
25. Combo #8 |
|
Ki Bon 2 Soo |
|
26. Standing Arm Lock |
Ki Bon 7 Soo |
||
27 Log Rolling Throw |
Son Mok 8 Soo |
||
28 |
Oht 2 Soo |
Eui Bok 1 Soo |
|
29 |
Finger Grab |
Finger Grab |
|
30 |
Wrist Break & Lock |
Ki Bon 8 Soo |
|
Eui Bok 6 Soo |
|||
Eui Bok 8 Soo |
|||
Eui Bok 9 Soo |
|||
Eui Bok 10 Soo |
|||
|
Eui Bok 11 Soo |
||
Eui Bok 12 Soo |
|||
Son Mok 11 Soo |
|||
Eui Bok 3 Soo |
|||
Ki Bon 11 Soo |
|||
Ki Bon 15 Soo |
|||
|
Wrist Break for Shoulder Grab |
||
Wrist Lock |
|||
Son Mok 15 Soo |
|||
Son Mok 19 Soo |
|||
5. Forward Wrist Throw |
|||
6. Elbow Wrist Throw |